Bob,
My ( usually minority ) opinion, it’s fine, and in many ways important, for old farts like us to experience, and form opinions about AI, in non-mission critical settings like our forum.
We’ll do a better job assimilating AI into our culture if we take the time to understand risks and benefits before we attempt to codify regulations… for our nation or our forum.
Americans have a history of assimilating disruptive technology faster than other cultures, by taking risks with early iterations of the idea and then working out how to equitably share the benefits of the idea with all participants in it’s refinement and/or deployment. My opinion is that in most cases our laws favor the inventor and/or implementation champion over others who contributed to the efforts to execute the vision. Nikola Tesla is one exception, but hey, he got a car named after him.
A example from our past. Yesterday there was a NYT article ( HERE ) about the Vanderbilt mansion in NYC that gives perspective to how long it takes our culture to assimilate disruptive a (mostly) beneficial idea and equitably share it’s benefits. In this case railroads.
As we know the “Commodore” was an Elon Musk kinda guy in the early 1800’s. The Vanderbilt mansion in NYC was built by his heirs with the fortune they inherited from his railroad businesses.
Not only was the Commodore was well rewarded in his lifetime, but it took his heirs over 100 years to reintegrate (spend) the fruits of his labors back into our economy.
I think we’ll eventually conclude that digital content ( like recordings of music and images of art) have some flexibility in how they might be used as inputs for other creative pursuits.
Yea, Gary’s fuzzy boats is a creative pursuit, and my attempt to relate AI to railroads is a bit of a stretch.
But seriously, the photos in the article are mind bending for anyone that knows present day 5th Avenue.
If you want to re-open the “Fun with AI” topic, send a personal message to me by clicking on this: @NS233_Bob_Neches
My position as moderator, subject as always to learning from what others think, is:
I’m not inclined to take down posts on the premise that it might offend someone else. I will take down posts if multiple requests show that the group consensus is that it’s offensive, or if I have strong confidence that such consensus is likely.
The question about Gary’s and Brian’s original post essential comes down to two questions: who does the original material “belong” to, and what constitutes fair use. In this case, my sense is:
A digital image of an artwork that has been posted on the public internet and sold to the original poster no longer “belongs” to the artist in the sense intended by the Forum rules. If it did, I’d have to delete pretty much every meme anyone shared. Taking/posting/modifying a picture inside a musuem with a “no photography” policy is wrong. Doing the same thing for a poster or billboard on a wall facing a public street is not.
Posting/modifying an image in this forum of a picture that is publically accessible by those criteria constitutes “fair use” as long as it is kept in the forum (which is private) and not used for profit. Credit to the original source is highly preferred. Having previously posted in other threads that this picture was his, I feel Gary not repeating it here is understandable and not worth pursuing.