Question - Internal Reef Lines

Hi All,
One of my winter projects is to address an issue with Soave’s internal reef lines. This was probably a pre-existing situation on Soave and may be present on other Nonsuch boats with internal reef lines.

Backstory - On the way back from the Rendezvous in Greenport we were on a broad reach headed west and a storm front overtook us resulting in some 30 knot wind and 5-6’ seas. We reefed and proceeded as the front approached. Since this was the heaviest air we’ve experienced with Soave, I figured it was a good time to reinspect our running rigging. I noticed the some of the reefline turning blocks mounted to the wishbone were loose. Closer inspection revealed that the stainless machine screws holding the block had begun to corrode the surrounding aluminum and had lost some of their bite.

( HERE ) Is a link to a short video that shows the situation better than I can explain.

My instinct is to add a backing plate that can be tapped to receive the screws, but I’d love to hear other ideas.

Secondary discoveries that might exist on other boats with internal reef lines. Maybe things worth checking at the next rigging inspection?

  1. On the starboard wishbone, Soave has internal 2nd reef and topping lift lines. I strip all lines for winter storage and pull a messenger line to pull lines back in the spring. This year I felt resistance when pulling the 2nd reef. I determined that the resistance was from a crossover with the topping lift. Seems like in previous years both were slack, but this year I had topping lift was tied off and fairly tight. I’ll triple check that both run free under tension in the spring.
  2. To get a better view of what was going on I removed the forward double block and found the beginnings of corrosion problem, plus debris in the wishbone that looks like the remains of an old mouse nest.


Please share any and all ideas on how to address my “loose screw” issue described in the video.

Thanks,
Rob…

Bigger screw.

What if you epoxied a thicker backing plate in place then tapped into that with larger screws?

Hi Rob if I understand your request - I had a similar situation on Aloki a few years back. I believe it’s a fairly simple fix.

First, determine what size bolts were in place. ( either a bolt gauge or a trip to the hardware store trying different nuts till it’s determined. ) Secondly , purchase high grade stainless bolts the next size up and make sure they fit through the car assembly or drill out to comply. Third - here opinions might vary but what I did was using an appropriate drill bit to make a larger hole and then tap new threads .

Let’s assume you have 10x24 bolts in place. If that’s the case you’ll need to move up to the next size - 12x24 Also we’ll assume you have enough room to expand the bolt pattern to accept three 12x24 bolts in a row ( visually I think you do) .

What I did was simply , steady and v slowly drill the existing holes to the new bolts size using the appropriate drill bit and then tapping new threads into the aluminum. Patience , skill and lube is the key. ( cutting oil is best - 3M sells a small tube) I’d also drill the center holes first , set the new bolts in place ( with the car in place) and then continue drilling opposite holes and setting bits into place. ( this avoids shifting the bolt pattern so they’ll line up as needed) Once all in place , remove , use an anti-seize cream and bolt back up. If you’d like to complicate it , fabricate and install a backing plate to cover all the bolts inside the boom. Could be two aluminum strips.

There are a number of videos that demonstrate the above appropriately and I’d maybe practice on a scrap of aluminum to gain expertise. Email if I can be of help , best , Gary

Bolt size/ tap drill bit size/ tap size

#10-24 0.190" #25 (0.1495") #10-24

#12-24 0.216" #17 (0.173") #12-24

What Gary said. (Except for feeling stronger than him about how much complication backing plates would entail.

I’d be careful with the backing plate path. If it’s aluminum, it’d be a corrosion issue with the screws and a lot of unnecessary hassle given that the next bigger size will do the job. If it’s stainless steel, it’ll be a bear to tap and could turn into a corrosion problem with the boom.

Epoxying it to the inside of the boom could be hard. You’d need it to work with the interior curvature of the boom, and it’d turn into a real P.I.T.A. if it gets detached during the installation process.

I have Milwaukee drill and tap bits that work really well with my impact driver. The first part drills the larger hole. As you go deeper, the next part taps the threads. As you withdraw it in reverse, it deburrs everything. With the impact driver and lubrication, it becomes a really quick and easy job.

-- Bob

Thanks all !

Sounds like the way to go is re-tap larger screws.

Need to order some machine screws and add appropriate sized taps to my growing collection. I’ll keep you posted on my progress.

I think it’s early enough in the corrosion process that I can get the new (larger) screws to bite. If it fails again I can always do the backing plate next time.

The aluminum in the vicinity of all stainless on Soave shows signs of corrosion. Whenever I disassemble, I clean, prime with zinc chromate and apply a suitable isolation layer ( either TEF45 or polycarbonate sheet) , and then reassemble.

Disassembly (nondestructive) is by far the hardest part of the process. I’d like to think I won’t have to revisit the same spot for 5 years and there are probably 200-300 places of interest where stainless touches aluminum on Soave. That works out to about 50 corrosion remediation/prevention events per season.

Incidentally, the plan for the backing plate would have been.

  1. Fabricate the plates with 6061-t6 aluminum bar.
  2. Use 4 lengths of threaded rod to hold the two plates in place, and slide the block assembly over the threaded rods.
  3. Start screws (coated with TEF45) in the third hole on each side.
  4. One by one back out the rod and start the other two screws on each side.
  5. Tighten the screws.
  6. Disassembly is the same process in reverse. Hopefully remembering there are backing plates.

I mention this because, I’m pretty sure at some point I’m going to find badly corroded screw holes that won’t support larger screws. I can refer to this post to remind me of the backing plate process and any improvements others suggest.

Sail on,
Rob…